RWE Stargazer Solar McKean County, PA

Pennsylvania land. New York’s grid.

RWE proposes a roughly 3,515-acre solar and battery project in Sergeant, Hamlin and Norwich. Its filings name 21 receiving waters and seek to connect to New York’s grid.

All 21 streams and their water quality classifications

RWE’s January stormwater report and the Chapter 102 pre-application meeting form name the same 21 receiving waters. The table shows Pennsylvania’s protected-use classification for each. The final discharge locations remain unverified.

Stormwater report, p. 3DEP meeting form, p. 1

HQ-CWF High Quality–Cold Water Fishes CWF Cold Water Fishes
Stream or tributaryPA water quality classification
Marvin Creek drainage
Marvin Creek HQ-CWF / CWFHQ-CWF from the source to Kane Creek. CWF on named downstream reaches.
Warner Brook HQ-CWF
Jet Brook HQ-CWF
Stone Dock Hollow HQ-CWF
Tributary 57785 to Warner Brook HQ-CWF
Bloomster Hollow CWF
Shelander Hollow CWF
Tributary 57768 to Bloomster Hollow CWF
Irons Hollow CWF
Tributary 57756 to Irons Hollow CWF
Potato Creek and Red Mill Brook drainages
Robbins Brook HQ-CWF
Donley Fork HQ-CWF
Boyer Brook HQ-CWF
Wernwag Hollow HQ-CWF
Browns Mill Hollow CWF
Tributary 57887 to Red Mill Brook CWF
Tributary 57886 to Red Mill Brook CWF
Tributary 57885 to Red Mill Brook CWF
Tributary 57884 to Red Mill Brook CWF
East Branch Clarion River drainage
Martin Run HQ-CWF
Tributary 50849 to Martin Run HQ-CWF

See DEP’s assessment for each stream Download the chart (CSV)

Stargazer Solar / Two project records

What the stormwater records say

The two pre-application records address stormwater differently. Each source gives the original wording and the recorded answer.

August 18, 2026 · DEP questionnaire

No

“Will the project involve discharge of construction related or clean stormwater to a dry swale, surface water, ground water or an existing sanitary sewer system or separate storm water system?”

Read question 51 and the recorded answer

Circulated Sept. 17, 2026 · Chapter 102 meeting form

Yes

“Stormwater discharges are proposed to HQ or EV surface waters, including wetlands.”

HQ means High Quality. EV means Exceptional Value. The same page checks “Yes” for known jurisdictional wetlands on the site.

See the marked boxes on page 1
Form excerpt listing receiving waters including Robbins Brook and marking Yes for proposed stormwater discharges to HQ or EV surface waters.
Detail from RWE’s meeting form, page 1. View full page · DEP’s September 17 email with the attachment

Start with the receiving-water list.

The January report traces 26 modeled drainage points to the 21 receiving waters. The report keeps those points in its post-development model and proposes infiltration basins to manage increased runoff. The available records leave the final outfall locations unverified.

Compare the drainage report, meeting form and permit correspondence

Stargazer I & II / New York Independent System Operator

Where would Stargazer plug in?

RWE’s two interconnection requests put the generating sites in McKean County, Pennsylvania and the proposed grid connection in NYISO Zone A. NYISO operates New York’s bulk electricity grid. Its workbook names New York State Electric & Gas (NYSEG) and the Homer City to Pierce Brook 345 kV line for both entries.

Summer capacity requested in NYISO’s March 26, 2026 study
ProjectSolarBatteryTotal
Stargazer I C24-175240 MW85 MW325 MW
Stargazer II C24-176240 MW85 MW325 MW
Combined requests480 MW170 MW650 MW

The two solar entries add up to the 480 MW in RWE’s township application. The additional 170 MW is battery capacity. A battery stores electricity for later discharge. Read NYISO’s technology breakdown, slide 41

What is actually scheduled?

NYISO’s August 31, 2026 queue lists July 2029 as the proposed commercial operation month for both entries. That is the developer’s target for starting operations. The records establish the requested route onto New York’s grid. They identify neither a power buyer nor a binding schedule to deliver electricity to a particular community.

Inspect both queue entries and the workbook →

Whose 77,000 homes?

RWE’s Sergeant Township application estimates first-year generation at 908,639 megawatt-hours. It compares that output with the annual use of more than 77,000 average U.S. homes. It does not promise service to 77,000 McKean County homes or identify a rate reduction for local customers.

Read RWE’s comparison, PDF page 3 →

A question for RWE. Has a buyer contracted for Stargazer’s electricity, capacity or renewable energy credits? If McKean County customers have an allocation or a bill credit, which agreement gives it to them?

Sergeant, Hamlin and Norwich townships / McKean County

Who gets a say on these 3,515 acres?

RWE’s application puts approximately 2,965 acres in Sergeant, 133 in Hamlin and 417 in Norwich. The proposed grid connection runs through New York’s operator. Residents here still have to deal with what happens at the fence line, in the streams and at the fire hall. Check the acreage by township, PDF page 2

Sergeant TownshipMarch 4, 2026

Seven residents spoke in opposition. The minutes record approval.

The meeting record says the floor was opened at the Clermont Fire Hall and names seven opponents. It records that the permit conditions were read and approved. The solar paragraph gives no speaker-by-speaker response or roll-call tally. Residents can read that paragraph in its entirety. The sheet is headed April 1 and identifies the meeting as March 4 in its opening sentence.

Read the one-page township record →
Public noticeBush v. Sergeant Township

What could residents learn before the vote?

In her complaint, Linda Bush said the agenda she saw inside the locked fire hall listed the solar matter only under “Old Business.” RWE’s petition to intervene said Bush spoke against the project and the board approved it with conditions. These are the parties’ accounts. The posted agenda, the posting time and the adopted permit conditions are the records that let residents assess what notice they had.

County protectionsMarch 20, 2026

RWE’s lawyer asked the county to put its position in writing.

Shawn Gallagher argued that the proposed county solar amendment could not be applied to Stargazer. He told the county solicitor that RWE would seek declaratory and injunctive relief if the county tried. He also wrote that Sergeant and Hamlin had approved their portions and that RWE intended to address Norwich later. The letter documents RWE’s position on that date. Residents can ask the county for its written response and the final conditions it considers enforceable.

Read Gallagher’s letter, PDF pages 1–2 →
Local benefits and costsRWE’s permit application

Which promises can the township enforce?

RWE estimated about $12.3 million for Sergeant over the project’s lifetime and about 20 permanent full-time jobs created or supported. It promised a removal bond and offered emergency-response training if requested. Residents can ask for the signed payment schedule, the bond amount and issuer, and the fire companies’ training and reimbursement agreements. Those documents show who is responsible if the project changes hands.

For the next township meeting. Ask the supervisors to publish the dated permit, every condition attached to it, the latest site plan and the written answers to residents’ questions. For runoff, ask RWE to point to each discharge location on the plan. See why Robbins Brook is named

Stargazer Solar / DEP Right-to-Know 2026-1754

Eight days in the Stargazer email trail

On September 16, the Army Corps reviewer sounded impressed. By September 24, he was asking how a site that size could avoid every stream and wetland. Here’s what he and two other officials wrote that week.

“I’m not sure how a 3,500 acre site doesn’t impact a stream or wetland anywhere.”
Tyler J. BintrimU.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Pittsburgh District
Read Bintrim’s email
  1. Tyler J. Bintrim · U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

    “Sounds like no impacts to streams or wetlands. That’s pretty impressive considering the size of this solar project.”
    Read the September 16 email
  2. Staci Gustafson · Assistant Regional Director, PA DEP

    “I reached out to Bob Jevin last week and asked him to consider handling this under Major Projects.”

    Gustafson wrote that she was still waiting for his answer.

    Read Gustafson’s email
  3. Sandy Thompson · District Manager, McKean County Conservation District

    “I’m sure you all understand the concern we have for this project especially with the amount of disturbance for this project and the potential environmental impact.”

    Thompson said she had contacted Manulife’s consulting forester to ask for a site visit.

    Read Thompson’s email
  4. Tyler J. Bintrim · U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

    “Pittsburgh Corps may be interested in a site visit.”

    This is the email in which Bintrim questioned how the project could avoid impacts. He closed with a request.

    “Keep us in the loop.”
    Read the entire September 24 message

How the Stargazer review boundary changed

On June 22, 2026, Civil & Environmental Consultants (CEC) told the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission that Stargazer’s new study area reached east and west of the original boundary and overlapped the former Wild Hollow project. Writing for RWE, CEC said the company had stopped pursuing Wild Hollow separately. The final Stargazer project boundary was still undetermined. Read CEC’s letter, p. 1

March 2025 screening map showing a largely contiguous area north of Clermont.

March 25, 2025

4,871.29 acres screened

The applicant said some activities would or might take place in a waterway or on its banks.

Read the waterway answer, p. 4
May 2026 screening map showing several areas around Clermont and Red Mill Road.

May 26, 2026

4,306.05 acres screened

The applicant said no activities would occur in waterways or on their banks, and some would occur within 100 feet.

Read the waterway answer, p. 7

Maps from the Pennsylvania Natural Diversity Inventory (PNDI) receipts. Black outlines mark the submitted boundary and red outlines mark its buffer. Each map has its own scale.

The revised screening area was 565.24 acres smaller overall, even with land added on both sides. Both figures describe the area checked for natural resources. The township filing separately listed about 3,515 acres. The amount that would be cleared is a different question.

What the field team found

Riveredge’s July 8 report combined the Stargazer and Wild Hollow fieldwork, including a May visit to the 209-acre “Okerlund Parcel.” The earlier Stargazer study identified four potential rattlesnake habitat features. The combined study identified ten in all, with three possible denning sites and seven possible gestation sites. Biologists reported no timber rattlesnake sightings during those visits.

Survey area, p. 3 Habitat, p. 7 Sightings, p. 10

What PFBC asked for

For potential rattlesnake dens, PFBC recommended moving disturbance 300 feet away or having a qualified biologist survey for the species if relocation was infeasible. It also requested a blue-spotted salamander survey after an earlier assessment identified 21 potential habitat features.

For bigmouth shiner and burbot, the agency asked about possible stream crossings, in-stream work, alternatives and affected wetland or waterway acreage. It said a fish survey might be warranted after reviewing those details.

Rattlesnakes, p. 2 Salamanders, pp. 3–4 Fish and crossings, p. 4

Read the six PFBC release records

The release includes submissions prepared for RWE and letters written by the commission. The PDFs retain the redactions supplied with the records.

For comparison, read pages 1–4 of the March 2025 screening receipt. Dates above follow the letters’ first pages. The July 23 Stargazer letter carries January 12 on its continuation pages.

01 / The core contradiction

What RWE promises in McKean County

RWE's public-facing messaging emphasizes power production, jobs, tax revenue, low visibility and limited operational traffic. The permit filing is where the actual physical project appears: arrays, BESS, substations, inverters, roads, fencing, electrical infrastructure and transmission.

RWE public pitch

480 MW. 77,000+ homes. Local benefits.

Those are the numbers a project page is designed to foreground. They are relevant—but they are not the whole project.

Open RWE's project page ↗
RWE filing

Thousands of acres plus BESS, roads, substations and transmission.

The Sergeant Township filing describes a +480 MWac facility on approximately 3,515 acres across Sergeant, Hamlin and Norwich, with battery storage and associated electrical infrastructure.

Read RWE's filing ↗
RWE public project size
480 MW

Public project description.

Local application area
≈3,515

Acres identified across Sergeant, Hamlin and Norwich in the local application.

03 / Money + agreements

Who secured the land and the transmission rights?

The public land record includes Stargazer-related options and easements. One recorded RWE agreement states that Schedule 1 was intended to be redacted for recording purposes. The public-record copy reviewed for this page includes that schedule and its listed easement payments.

Recorded Stargazer-related agreement
$2.001M

Listed easement-payment installments after option exercise: $1,000 followed by five $400,000 installments. The agreement also separately identifies option payments and says option payments are credited against the easement payment.

Open Instrument 202600051 ↗
“Grantor shall fully support and cooperate with Grantee…”
Section 18 • recorded easement agreement
What the document shows

RWE negotiated transmission and access rights, payment terms, confidentiality over financial terms, property-use protections and cooperation obligations. Those terms are part of the recorded agreement.

What the payments are identified as

The agreement identifies the payments as consideration for the easement option and easements. This page reports the amounts in that contractual context.

Source note: Instrument #202600051 is presented here as a public-record land agreement. The page summarizes its terms and links readers to the underlying record.

NEW / RWE is separately litigating major supplier guarantees. Explore the 2026 contract dispute and original filings ↗

SPECIAL REPORT · 2026 SUPPLY CONTRACT DISPUTE

THE CONTRACT FIGHT
BEHIND THE PANELS.

German-based RWE and a U.S. solar manufacturer are fighting over a five-year panel supply contract originally signed with Trina Solar’s U.S. business. Their competing court filings put warranties, specifications, payment guarantees, and project economics under the microscope.

PUBLIC RECORD14COURT DOCUMENTS
READ THEM YOURSELF

Important: No document reviewed here proves these disputed panels were intended for Stargazer. These are competing claims in ongoing litigation, not findings that RWE, Trina, or T1 committed wrongdoing. The project-specific procurement connection remains unverified.

THE MONEY AT ISSUEGuaranty limits — not amounts awarded
01 / T1’S CLAIMU.S. manufacturer → German parent
$100M

T1 pursues RWE’s parent-company guarantee.

T1 says RWE wrongfully refused to honor payment obligations after trying to terminate the supply agreement. RWE disputes the underlying allegations.

Read T1’s filed complaint ↗
02 / RWE’S CLAIMU.S. RWE unit → Singapore guarantor
$40M

RWE pursues Trina’s supplier guarantee.

RWE says the supplier failed to deliver promised safeguards, reports, and specifications, causing financial and project-design harm. The supplier contests RWE’s account.

Read RWE’s filed complaint ↗

Separate guaranties arising from the same broader supply dispute. Do not add the two guarantee caps together as if they were proven losses or a single claim. The original California contract case is CGC-26-632187.

GERMANYRWE AG

Parent guarantor pursued by T1

UNITED STATESRWE Investco / T1

Supply-contract buyers and manufacturer

CHINESE ORIGINSTrina Solar

Original supplier’s corporate group

SINGAPORETrina affiliate

Supplier guarantor sued by RWE

The original agreement was signed in July 2023 with Trina Solar (U.S.), Inc. T1 acquired the manufacturing operations at the end of 2024. A Chinese parent company’s history does not, by itself, prove the current U.S. manufacturer is Chinese-owned or that Stargazer will use these panels.

THE MOST REVEALING COMPARISON

RWE’s own legal theory: documentation matters.

When a developer designs and finances a solar facility, supplier specifications and security arrangements can affect project economics. That's what RWE argues in its California complaint. The manufacturer disputes the claimed violations.

RWE’S ALLEGATIONS · CALIFORNIA COMPLAINT

“We planned around the specifications.”

RWE alleges that forecast module wattages, absent financial audits and missing surety protection contributed to increased costs and jeopardized multiple projects.

Read complaint, especially pp. 10–14 ↗
T1’S RESPONSE · ANSWER / CROSS-COMPLAINT

“You inspected and accepted the products.”

T1 says the products complied with its reading of the contract and that RWE attempted to exit after accepting deliveries. T1 also acknowledges that most produced modules were 615 watts or less.

Read answer, especially pp. 21–23 ↗
MCKEAN COUNTY / THE UNANSWERED CONNECTION

Where does Stargazer fit?

The cases do not name Stargazer as a project receiving the disputed panels. RWE should be asked to identify the manufacturer and models currently specified for Stargazer, whether the supply disagreement changed any project design, and the enforceable guarantees that protect local landowners and municipalities.

Examine the 14 court files
HOW WE GOT HERE Swipe to explore ↔
Contract signed

RWE and Trina U.S. sign long-term module supply agreement.

Factory changes hands

T1 acquires the U.S. manufacturing operation.

Termination disputed

RWE sends a termination notice that T1 rejects.

California claims

RWE sues; T1 files its cross-complaint January 22.

T1 goes after parent

T1 sues RWE AG in New York on payment guarantee.

RWE sues guarantor

RWE files New York federal action against Trina affiliate.

Case moved to federal court

RWE AG removes T1's New York action to federal court.

OPEN SOURCE / NO PAYWALL

THE COURT VAULT.

Every uploaded court record, labeled by what it actually contains. Search by party, issue, exhibit, case number, or document type.

14ORIGINAL PDF FILES

Showing all 14 documents

FILE 01 / 14Claim / response

Jan 7, 2026 · 21 pages

RWE’s California complaint

RWE alleges supplier breaches

RWE alleges missing surety protection and cost audits, disputed module wattages, and resulting project-design and financial harm. These are allegations, not findings.

CGC-26-632187Read PDF
FILE 02 / 14Claim / response

Jan 22, 2026 · 10 pages

T1’s California cross-complaint

Supplier contests termination

T1 claims RWE wrongfully terminated the five-year agreement and failed to pay for or collect modules. RWE contests that account.

CGC-26-632187Read PDF
FILE 03 / 14Claim / response

Mar 9, 2026 · 9 pages

T1’s complaint against RWE AG

The $100M parent-guaranty claim

T1 seeks to enforce RWE AG’s payment guaranty, capped at $100 million. The cap is not an established debt or a judgment.

1:26-cv-07049Read PDF
FILE 04 / 14Claim / response

Aug 14, 2026 · 15 pages

RWE’s complaint against Trina guarantor

The $40M supplier-guaranty claim

RWE seeks enforcement of a separate guarantee against a Singapore-based Trina affiliate, capped at $40 million. The claim is disputed.

1:26-cv-06975Read PDF
FILE 05 / 14Court procedure

Aug 18, 2026 · 6 pages

Notice of removal to federal court

T1 v. German parent RWE AG

RWE AG moved the parent-guaranty case from New York state court to the Southern District of New York. This is a procedural filing, not a merits ruling.

1:26-cv-07049Read PDF
FILE 06 / 14Claim / response

Feb 9, 2026 · 42 pages

T1 answer and affirmative defenses

Detailed point-by-point response

T1 denies RWE’s central claims, argues the supplier met the operative contract terms, and alleges RWE accepted modules after inspection.

CGC-26-632187Read PDF
FILE 07 / 14Court procedure

Filed as exhibit Aug 18, 2026 · 8 pages

New York docket and procedural orders

State-court docket history

Includes New York state-court case information and selected orders attached to the August federal notice of removal.

1:26-cv-07049Read PDF
FILE 08 / 14Court procedure

Filed as exhibit Aug 18, 2026 · 31 pages

Proof of service in Germany

Hague Convention documents

German service records and court papers showing delivery to RWE AG. Procedural record; not evidence resolving the contract dispute.

1:26-cv-07049Read PDF
FILE 09 / 14Corporate evidence

Filed as exhibit Aug 18, 2026 · 8 pages

Trina/T1 registration and name changes

California and Texas records

Corporate filings identifying the manufacturing entity and subsequent name changes from Trina Solar to T1.

1:26-cv-07049Read PDF
FILE 10 / 14Corporate evidence

Filed as exhibit Aug 18, 2026 · 2 pages

Texas associated-entity registration

Corporate ownership exhibit

Texas Secretary of State record for T1 G1 Dallas Associated Entity LLC and its recorded management information.

1:26-cv-07049Read PDF
FILE 11 / 14Corporate evidence

Filed as exhibit Aug 18, 2026 · 2 pages

Delaware corporate registration

T1 G1 Dallas Midco Inc.

Delaware Division of Corporations filing search documenting T1 G1 Dallas Midco Inc.

1:26-cv-07049Read PDF
FILE 12 / 14Corporate evidence

Filed as exhibit Aug 18, 2026 · 6 pages

T1 G1 Dallas Midco business profile

Background ownership record

Third-party business profile attached as background corporate evidence. Figures in such profiles may be incomplete.

1:26-cv-07049Read PDF
FILE 13 / 14Corporate evidence

Dec 31, 2025 · 3 pages

T1 interested-parties disclosure

From a separate Texas proceeding

Corporate disclosure filed in a separate Texas staffing dispute; included here as an exhibit supporting corporate identity.

4:25-cv-01470Read PDF
FILE 14 / 14Separate proceeding

Dec 31, 2025 · 20 pages

T1 v. TKO staffing complaint

Separate case, not a claim against RWE

A distinct lawsuit about T1’s staffing contractor. RWE is not accused in this action; the filing was used as background corporate evidence.

4:25-cv-01470Read PDF

Source handling: The PDFs are publicly filed court papers and attachments. “Complaint,” “answer,” and “cross-complaint” describe a party's position, not what a judge found. Exhibit 12 in the numbering is a separate T1–staffing contractor case included for corporate background, not a case against RWE. Documents reflect what was uploaded to this archive; consult live court dockets for subsequent rulings.

Continue to Stargazer permits + land records ↗
04 / The people in the record

What RWE told McKean County

In February, RWE’s development manager wrote that counsel believed Stargazer would be grandfathered. In March, RWE’s attorney put the company’s position on the proposed county ordinance in writing.

First page of Shawn Gallagher March 20 2026 letter
RWE legal counsel

Shawn N. Gallagher

Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney • counsel identified in RWE Stargazer correspondence

In the March 20, 2026 letter to McKean County counsel, Gallagher argues against applying the proposed County solar amendment to Stargazer and states that if the County adopts and attempts to impose it, RWE would seek declaratory and injunctive relief.

“It would be RWE's preference not to litigate this matter.”
Read the letter ↗
Public-record email from RWE development manager Evan Good
RWE development manager

Evan Good

Utility-scale development • Stargazer correspondence

In a February 27, 2026 public-record email, Good said RWE had already started township permitting, had applications pending in Sergeant and Hamlin, was working on an NPDES submission, and had been advised by counsel that Stargazer would be grandfathered.

“We want to confirm that we are all on the same page.”

Open the February 27 email image →

05 / What the filings actually contain

What changes at the fence line?

RWE’s permit and the agency reviews identify questions about forest clearing, streams, battery storage and who pays for removal.

02 • BESS

Battery storage is part of the permit—not a footnote.

The local application describes battery energy storage alongside solar arrays, substations, inverters and transmission infrastructure.

Read the permit ↗
03 • WILDLIFE

The site has undergone protected-species review.

The July 23 Stargazer letter discusses ten potential rattlesnake habitat features in the combined investigation and requests further information about protected fish.

Read PFBC’s July letter ↗
04 • EQUIPMENT

Preliminary specifications can change.

The Sergeant filing includes preliminary manufacturer specifications and says updated specifications will be provided later if project components change.

Read the equipment exhibits ↗
05 • DECOMMISSIONING

What is removed, how deep, and who pays?

Decommissioning obligations and financial security deserve close review because the project would leave extensive infrastructure across a large footprint.

Read the decommissioning plan ↗
06 • LOCAL RULES

RWE sought a grandfathering position while county rules were being debated.

RWE correspondence shows active concern over whether proposed County standards would apply to Stargazer.

Read counsel's letter ↗
06 / Timeline

The project record stretches back years.

Selected project filings, agency letters and field reports, in date order.

SEPTEMBER 10, 2021

Early land-control reference

Later recorded documents reference an RWE option dating to September 10, 2021 involving John Hancock / Manulife-related property.

SEPTEMBER 17, 2024

Two requests to connect to New York’s grid

RWE submitted C24-175 and C24-176 for Stargazer I and II, both in McKean County and NYISO Zone A. Inspect the two entries →

MARCH–MAY 2025

PNDI / PFBC review expands

Agency correspondence identifies a solar + storage project, uncertain waterway impacts and species-review issues.

JULY–OCTOBER 2025

Timber Rattlesnake habitat assessment and follow-up

PFBC later discusses potential denning/overwintering and gestation habitat elements.

JANUARY 2026

Blue-Spotted Salamander review continues

PFBC correspondence discusses 21 potential habitat elements and requested presence/absence work.

MARCH 4–20, 2026

Sergeant records opposition and approval. RWE challenges county review.

The township minutes identify seven opponents. On March 20, RWE’s counsel warned the county about applying its proposed solar amendment. Read the minutes and the letter →

MARCH 26, 2026

NYISO separates solar from battery capacity

The study lists 240 MW of solar and 85 MW of battery capacity for each Stargazer entry. Read slide 41 →

MAY 26 – JUNE 22, 2026

Stargazer’s revised screening boundary

The May receipt lists 4,306.05 acres. In June, CEC described the overlap with the former Wild Hollow project. Compare the receipts ↗

JULY 8–23, 2026

Combined habitat report and PFBC follow-up

Riveredge reported ten potential rattlesnake habitat features. PFBC’s July 23 Stargazer letter addressed the combined fieldwork and requested stream-crossing details. Read the July records ↗

AUGUST 18, 2026

The questionnaire records “No” on stormwater discharge

Question 51 and the Chapter 102 meeting form describe discharge differently. Compare the wording ↗

SEPTEMBER 16–24, 2026

The Army Corps asks about streams and wetlands

Two emails from Tyler Bintrim bracket DEP and conservation district correspondence about the scale of the proposed disturbance. Read the four messages ↗

OCTOBER 6, 2026

Conservation district schedules a project tour

Sandy Thompson invited recipients to an October 30 site visit. Read the invitation ↗

Project records

Stargazer Solar documents

Browse the complete document index → Find the New York grid records, township papers, land agreements, water reviews, released emails and court filings by subject.

The court archive includes 14 primary court PDFs from the RWE–Trina/T1 dispute. Go to the interactive litigation vault ↗

PRIMARY FILING

RWE Sergeant Township Permit Application

RWE Solar Development, LLC solar system permit application and project narrative submitted for Sergeant Township review, including project scope, site-plan exhibits, BESS references, stormwater materials, decommissioning materials, and supporting exhibits.

Open PDF ↗
LEGAL CORRESPONDENCE

RWE Legal Letter to McKean County

March 20, 2026 letter from RWE counsel regarding the McKean County SALDO, proposed solar ordinance language, grandfathering claims, and potential litigation positions involving the Stargazer Solar Project.

Open PDF ↗
AGENCY RECORD

CEC / PFBC PNDI Submission - Solar and Storage Project Area

March 26, 2025 CEC submission on behalf of RWE describing Stargazer as a utility-scale solar and storage facility with solar arrays, battery storage, appurtenant structures, access routes, ongoing natural-resource delineations, and uncertain waterway impacts.

Open PDF ↗
AGENCY LETTER

PFBC Species Impact Review - April 2025

PFBC SIR #61250 correspondence identifying Timber Rattlesnake, Blue-Spotted Salamander, Bigmouth Shiner, and Burbot review issues for Stargazer Renewable Development.

Open PDF ↗
ENVIRONMENTAL RECORD

CEC / PFBC Response and Project Maps - May 2025

May 9, 2025 CEC correspondence on behalf of RWE requesting additional information on Bigmouth Shiner and Burbot habitat, noting uncertain waterway impacts, and including project-area maps.

Open PDF ↗
AGENCY LETTER

PFBC Species Impact Review - May 2025

PFBC SIR #61250 follow-up correspondence again addressing Timber Rattlesnake, Blue-Spotted Salamander, Bigmouth Shiner, and Burbot review issues and additional evaluation needs.

Open PDF ↗
CONSULTANT REPORT

Timber Rattlesnake Habitat Assessment - July 2025

July 10, 2025 Timber Rattlesnake habitat assessment prepared for CEC / RWE after field visits in late June and early July 2025, evaluating potential habitat within the Stargazer investigation area.

Open PDF ↗
AGENCY RECORD

PFBC Species Impact Review - October 2025

PFBC SIR #61250 correspondence discussing four identified potential Timber Rattlesnake habitat elements, including potential denning and gestation habitat, and additional Blue-Spotted Salamander / fish-species review issues.

Open PDF ↗
AGENCY LETTER

PFBC Species Impact Review - January 2026

PFBC SIR #61250 correspondence discussing Timber Rattlesnake protections, Blue-Spotted Salamander habitat findings, requested presence / absence surveys, and ongoing rare or protected fish-species review needs.

Open PDF ↗
ENVIRONMENTAL RECORD

John Hancock / Manulife Option Record

Recorded memorandum involving John Hancock Life Insurance Company, Manulife Investment Management Timberland and Agriculture Inc., and RWE Solar Development, LLC, including option-to-purchase record details and related property descriptions.

Open PDF ↗
PRIMARY FILING

Lyme New York Headwaters Easement / 2021 RWE Option Reference

Recorded Grant of Easement involving John Hancock Life & Health Insurance Company / Manulife, Lyme New York Headwaters LLC, and RWE Solar Development, LLC. The document states that Grantor and RWE entered into an Option to Purchase dated September 10, 2021, as amended and assigned, and that the option remained in full force and effect as of the 2025 agreement.

Open PDF ↗
LEGAL CORRESPONDENCE

Okerlund Exclusive Option to Purchase - 202504113

Recorded memorandum of exclusive option to purchase involving David A. Okerlund, Tanya R. Okerlund, and RWE Solar Development, LLC. Instrument 202504113, recorded December 15, 2025.

Open PDF ↗
AGENCY RECORD

Okerlund Transmission Line and Access Easement - 202504114

Recorded option and transmission line and access easement involving David A. Okerlund, Tanya R. Okerlund, and RWE Solar Development, LLC. Instrument 202504114, recorded December 15, 2025.

Open PDF ↗
PUBLIC LAND RECORD

Okerlund Exclusive Option to Purchase - 202600049

Recorded memorandum of exclusive option to purchase involving David A. Okerlund, Tanya R. Okerlund, and RWE Solar Development, LLC. Instrument 202600049, recorded January 8, 2026.

Open PDF ↗
ENVIRONMENTAL RECORD

Okerlund Transmission Line and Access Easement - 202600051

Recorded option and transmission line and access easement involving David A. Okerlund, Tanya R. Okerlund, and RWE Solar Development, LLC. Instrument 202600051, recorded January 8, 2026.

Open PDF ↗
08 / Corrections, sources & confidential tips

See something wrong, incomplete or missing? Send the record.

Corrections are welcome. If you believe this page contains an inaccurate fact, outdated information, missing context or a misleading characterization, tell us exactly what should change and provide the best available supporting source. You may also use this form for new public records, screenshots or project information. Name and email are optional. Do not submit anything illegally obtained.

Fact correctionMissing contextUpdated public recordSource documentConfidential tip
Allowed: PDF, PNG, JPG, JPEG, WEBP. Existing PMCW upload/security handling remains in place.

Clermont Solar / Energix A separate McKean County project

Why did the Governor’s Office come up in a DEP email?

“I don’t think we want to be negotiating penalties with Govs office present.”
Erin K. WellsRegional Director, PA DEP Northwest Regional Office
Read the redacted email, page 2
Read Wells’s full paragraph

“OTO is stating that Energix wants an in-person meeting to reset and make sure everyone is on the same page. Without the appeal dropped, counsel would have to be present if we entertained the request and I don’t think we want to be negotiating penalties with Govs office present.”

What prompted the remark?

Fifteen minutes earlier, DEP’s Ronald Lybrook reported that inspectors had found problems with sediment basins and erosion controls. He said DEP was still waiting for requested records and that Clermont’s appeal was pending.

Wells told colleagues that Energix wanted an in-person meeting. She wrote that counsel would have to attend if DEP entertained the request while the appeal remained open. The remark about the Governor’s Office was hers.

What does the docket say?

On July 29, the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board closed docket 2026-031-B after Clermont Solar LLC withdrew its appeal. The order gives no penalty terms. Neither record identifies anyone from the Governor’s Office who attended a meeting or influenced a penalty.

Read the July 29 order

Disclaimer & corrections policy

This site contains commentary, analysis and opinion based on public records and other identified sources. We make a good-faith effort to distinguish documented facts, attributed statements, allegations, estimates and our own analysis. Records can be incomplete, revised or interpreted differently, and we may occasionally get something wrong.

If you believe any factual statement is inaccurate, incomplete, outdated or missing important context, please send the correction through the form below and, whenever possible, include the underlying document, filing, agency record, correspondence or other verifiable source. We will review credible corrections and update the page when the evidence supports a change. Nothing on this page should be read as an agency finding, court finding or allegation of unlawful conduct unless expressly identified and sourced as such.

Submit a correction or source

Stargazer is too consequential for a glossy project page to be the whole story.

Read the permit. Read the agency correspondence. Read the recorded agreements. Compare the claims against the documents and keep the public record organized.

✎ Corrections / Tips